This one was a run away. The 2006 game (Harline is still open) won in a land slide with 86% of the vote. The 2000 and 2001 game tied for second with 5% each. The 2007 and 2009 games each received a token 2%.
My vote would go to the 2006 game as well. Besides ending with one of the most dramatic plays in BYU football history, the fact that this was the first win over Utah in five year, that 2006 was the renaissance of BYU football, and that BYU had to score 19 points in the fourth quarter to win (as opposed to leading most the game and blowing it in the fourth quarter in 2000, 2007, and 2009) all make the 2006 finish the best in my mind.
Thanks to everyone who voted. Don't forget to vote in the new poll, "If you could change one play from the Utah game, which play would it be?" I am purposely leaving off the final Mitch Payne field goal attempt to hopefully avoid a landslide outcome.